# Otterly.ai Prompt Quality Assessment

**Date**: 2025-12-10

## Current Prompt Analysis

### Distribution by Type

- **Total Prompts**: 50
- **Keyword-only (≤3 words)**: 8 prompts (16%)
- **Short query (4-8 words)**: 35 prompts (70%)
- **Conversational (9+ words)**: 7 prompts (14%)

### Word Count Statistics

- **Average word count**: 5.2 words
- **Minimum word count**: 1 word
- **Maximum word count**: 12 words
- **Target range**: 10-25 words (NONE meet this standard)

### Examples

**Keyword-only (≤3 words):**

- "schichtplanung"
- "zeiterfassung"
- "schichtplan"
- "dienstplan tvöd"
- "Beste Schichtplan Software"

**Short query (4-8 words):**

- "wann muss ein dienstplan aushängen tvöd"
- "arbeitsrecht dienstplan tvöd"
- "zeiterfassung gastronomie"
- "Ordio vs Planday"
- "Alternative zu Planday"

**Conversational (9+ words):**

- "wann muss spätestens der dienstplan vorliegen"
- "wie früh muss ein dienstplan aushängen"
- "dienstplan wie lange im voraus tvöd"

## Issues Identified

1. **Not Conversational**: 84% of prompts are keywords or short queries, not full conversational sentences
2. **Missing Context**: Most prompts lack industry context, use case, or specific needs
3. **Not Question Format**: Many prompts are statements or keyword lists, not questions
4. **Too Short**: Average 5.2 words vs. target 10-25 words
5. **Not Natural**: Prompts don't mirror how users actually talk to AI assistants

## Transformation Needed

All prompts need to be transformed from:

- Keywords → Conversational questions with context
- Short queries → Expanded with industry/use case context
- Simple comparisons → Detailed comparison questions

## Target Format Examples

**Before**: "schichtplanung"
**After**: "Welche Software eignet sich am besten für die Schichtplanung in der Gastronomie?"

**Before**: "Ordio vs Planday"
**After**: "Wie unterscheidet sich Ordio von Planday für die Schichtplanung?"

**Before**: "zeiterfassung gastronomie"
**After**: "Welche Zeiterfassungssoftware eignet sich für Restaurants und Cafés?"